A company offers your law firm twenty “qualified leads” a month. The price looks reasonable, and you have available bandwidth for more clients at the moment, but before you sign, there's a question that the proposal doesn't seem to answer: namely, “what has to happen for that company to count someone as a qualified lead?”

Perhaps the person asked to speak with your firm about a service you provide, or perhaps they filled out a general legal-help form and the company plans to send their details to several firms. Both proposals might call that person a lead, but the conversation your team is about to have could be very different depending on what the person expected when they asked for help.

Before you can judge the price, you need to understand what the person expected, what the provider actually checked, and what your team will receive, because those details determine whether the service fits the way your firm takes on clients.

Key takeaways

  • Ask to see the ads and pages that generate inquiries, including what people are told about who will contact them and whether their details go to more than one firm.
  • Define “qualified” in writing so everyone knows what the provider checks, while keeping the decision about accepting the legal work with your attorneys.
  • Compare the total cost with what happens to the people who inquire, including completed consultations and signed agreements to hire the firm. Keep duplicate contacts and unresolved inquiries separate so they don't distort the comparison.

Find out whether you're buying marketing work or supplied inquiries

If an agency manages advertising that sends people to your firm's website, you're paying for the campaign work and advertising, while your team handles the inquiries the campaign produces.

A provider that operates its own directory or website may instead charge to send inquiries to participating firms, which means the person asking for help may have contacted that provider without knowing which firm would receive their details.

Because a company can offer both services, ask what your particular agreement includes: who controls the advertising account and website, what access your firm will have to inquiry records, and what happens to that access if you stop paying?

The answers affect what you can inspect or change. For example, if an ad on your firm's account promises a service you don't offer, you can have the campaign manager correct it, but if the inquiry came through someone else's website, you need to know whether that provider will show you the page and correct misleading wording there.

Before discussing volume, ask the provider to walk you through one example from the advertisement to the information your firm receives. A demonstration with test details is enough; you don't need another person's confidential information to understand the process.

Read what the person sees before submitting the form

Start with the page where someone asks for help. Does it name your firm, present a list of firms, or offer to connect the person with an attorney without naming one?

Then read the form and confirmation message. Do they explain who may contact the person? Is the inquiry sent only to your firm, or can several firms receive it? Does “exclusive” mean the provider won't share that inquiry, and are there exceptions in the contract?

Ask what the person is told about being contacted and how the provider records that agreement. Don't assume a form submission authorizes every later use of the information; have the firm review the actual wording and planned contact practices.

That wording shapes the conversation your team will have, because someone expecting a call from one named attorney may be confused when several firms call. Likewise, if the page promises an immediate attorney consultation but the first call only collects basic details, explain that first step accurately before the person submits the form.

Agree on what “qualified” means before paying for it

A provider may use “qualified” to mean that a form contains a working phone number and the person selected a legal service, while your firm may mean that the person needs work you handle, in a place where your lawyers can provide it, and is ready to discuss hiring you. Unless you resolve that difference before signing, the provider could deliver exactly what it promised while your team sees inquiries it can't use.

Work with your attorneys and intake staff to define what the provider can check. Intake is the part of the firm's work that involves receiving requests for help, gathering appropriate initial information, and arranging the next step, so those staff members can explain which details they need before passing an inquiry to an attorney.

Consider a hypothetical estate-planning firm that handles wills and trusts: a request to prepare a will appears relevant, while a request for criminal defense doesn't. Even the will inquiry needs further review, however, because the firm must establish whether its lawyers can advise on the person's situation, whether a conflict prevents it from acting, and whether the person wants to proceed after discussing the service and fees. For example, someone might ask the firm to act against a person it already represents, creating a potential conflict of interest for the lawyers.

The provider's screening can help identify obvious mismatches, but it doesn't replace the firm's decision about accepting the work.

Put the agreed criteria in the contract, along with which inquiries you'll be charged for and when you can request a credit. For example, if the contract promises estate-planning inquiries from a particular state but someone wants criminal defense in another state, will you still be charged? You need to know what evidence would support a credit request and how long you have to make it, as well as how the provider handles repeat inquiries and incorrect contact details.

A shared definition makes it possible to resolve those questions using the agreement, rather than arguing over whether a lead “felt qualified.”

Have a lawyer review the arrangement and the public claims

The responsible attorney should review how the provider is paid, what it says about the firm, and how it selects which firms receive inquiries.

The American Bar Association's commentary on Model Rule 7.2 explains that lawyers may pay for generating client leads under specified conditions, including limits on recommending the lawyer and requirements concerning the communications and payment arrangement. Because this is a model rule, your attorney still needs to check the rules that actually apply where your firm practices.

Give the attorney the real ads, pages, form wording, and proposed contract so they can assess what the provider actually does, rather than relying on its description of itself as a marketing company. For example, its website may imply that it independently evaluated the firm's ability to handle someone's legal problem, while the contract describes a paid advertising arrangement.

That review should also confirm that any advertised fees, credentials, availability, or results accurately represent the firm and have its approval. Once the claims have been checked, agree on who will review later changes so the approved version isn't quietly replaced by something different.

Test whether inquiries reach someone who can respond

Before relying on the service, submit a clearly labeled test inquiry and check that it reaches the firm's inbox or intake software with the information your team needs, and that the person responsible for responding receives the notification. If the service supplies phone calls, test what happens during office hours and when nobody answers.

Agree on who handles each type of inquiry and who covers an absence, because a provider can deliver a genuine request for help that goes unanswered if everyone at the firm assumes someone else is replying.

Keep detailed discussions of the person's legal situation within the firm's approved intake process, because information from a prospective client can require protection even when the firm is never hired. ABA Model Rule 1.18 addresses those duties, so the responsible attorney should review what the provider needs to collect or receive under the rules that apply to your firm.

When an inquiry doesn't become a client, record the reason you actually know: someone requesting criminal defense from an estate-planning firm needs a service the firm doesn't provide, whereas someone who hasn't answered a return call is still an unresolved inquiry. If you group both under “bad leads,” you won't be able to distinguish requests the firm can't help with from people your team simply hasn't reached yet.

Compare the full cost with what the inquiries produce

Before comparing prices, ask what each quote includes, because an agency's management fee may be separate from the money paid to an advertising platform, while a lead provider may charge per inquiry and add a setup fee. Include those costs on both sides of the comparison and consider the staff time each arrangement requires, so a lower headline price doesn't hide expenses you'll still have to pay.

Suppose, in a hypothetical example, one service costs $2,000 and supplies twenty separate requests for help, counting each person's inquiry once, which gives you a service cost of $100 per inquiry. If two of those people sign agreements to hire the firm, often called signed engagements, that same $2,000 works out to $1,000 per signed engagement: $2,000 divided by two.

Now suppose another service costs $3,000 and supplies fifteen distinct inquiries. Its cost per inquiry is higher, at $200, but if five people sign agreements to hire the firm, its service cost per signed engagement is lower, at $600: $3,000 divided by five.

The first service looks cheaper when you compare inquiries, while the second looks cheaper when you compare signed engagements, which is why the price of a lead alone can't tell you what it costs to bring in a client. These invented figures demonstrate the calculation rather than a benchmark or a recommendation to buy either service; you'd still need to account for the cost of handling inquiries and doing the legal work, along with the fees actually collected, before judging which arrangement is more profitable.

Allow comparable time for people to decide whether to hire you, too, because inquiries received eight weeks ago have had more time to become clients than inquiries received last week. Keep following the people in each original group and update what happened to them, rather than dividing this month's costs by agreements signed this month when some of those clients may have first contacted you much earlier.

Decide what you need to learn before expanding

For an initial trial, agree on the spending limit, what the provider will deliver, and when you'll review the results. Ask for a report that separates inquiries received, people successfully contacted, consultations completed, and agreements signed. A consultation booked for next week isn't a completed consultation, and an unanswered inquiry isn't proof that the person was unsuitable.

For the provider to calculate a reliable cost per signed engagement, it needs to know which of its inquiries led to agreements to hire your firm; without that information, it can't support the figure in its report. Work with the responsible attorney to decide what limited feedback can be shared for that purpose without disclosing unnecessary confidential information.

At the review, use what you learned to choose the next action. If inquiries repeatedly concern work the firm doesn't handle, inspect the ads, pages, and screening criteria. If the requests fit but messages aren't reaching the intake team, fix delivery before buying more. If the process works and the costs are acceptable, you have a reason to consider expanding, while continuing to track unresolved inquiries.

That's what you should be buying: a service you can understand well enough to evaluate, with clear expectations for both the prospective client and your firm. A promise of twenty leads tells you very little until you know what those twenty people were offered and what happens after they ask for help.

Morpheus Consulting Inc. can help you review how a lead-generation service attracts inquiries and how your firm responds, so you can decide whether the next improvement belongs in the advertising, website, provider agreement, or intake process.